Every constructor has one of “those”; a puzzle that resisted sooo many efforts that they thought it was done, and this one is mine. I got this idea (some may recognize it) from a Gaffney puzzle well over a year ago and struggled with it since. It has undergone at least three MAJOR rewrites and four or more minor ones. It has also been tested by nearly 10 people. Finally it made it through two testers with the correct answer. My "official" testers were, lbray53, rjy, Pchow, Barbara K, and another crossword solving friend Dave Schrager.
One would assume that after all that it is pretty close to perfect, and one would assume wrong. I am sure there are still problems with it, not the least of which is its difficulty level. Try as I might I cannot get this down from a Puma/Lion. It is a tricky mechanism to see and from there it is several steps. BUT, it is different and people have been extolling “different”, perhaps because we are becoming jaded?
This one is a Puma at least, but the mechanism is legit and there are some signposts, so I am releasing it into the wild for a ride in the Madhatter’s teacup.
Kitten
Calico
Persian
֎Puma
Lion
Nudges will be Friday and the reveal, unless there are still some solvers coming in, will be Sunday.
Wow, 7 hours into its run, 6 solvers and two entries on the MEOW board...I think this kitty needs some motivation to leave the bag!
NUDGES:
Nudge 1] The title is both a commentary on subtlety and a homonym.
Nudge 2] 39A is obviously important and suggests a search for 3 x 5 configurations with a distinct similarity.
Nudge 3] The graphic for the puzzle reveals the similarity.
Nudge 4] Meta puzzles usually have identifiers that people can use to their advantage. Some decks of cards are no different; they too have identifiers for the same purpose.
Nudge 5] You may think the "thing" is not consistent, but it is. You just may have to consider 48A to see why.
Nudge 6] Once you've identified the "thing" you will probably need to consider 54D to help you round for home.
Nudge 7] Once that is done there is just one more step, but you will probably have figured that out already.
THE REVEAL:
There are 5 “cards” (3 x 5 set of squares) with a distinct pattern.
? X ?
X ? X
If one takes those letters (the ?’s - so BCDAG) and “translates them as per 54D (particularly if you turned some of them 90 degrees left or right as per 48A) you get
2, 3, 4, 1, 7 and the letters in those “squares” are MAGIC
MAGIC, the meta answer
For a graphic representation of the solve go to: