Explanation: The five longest across entries all are one letter away from having a string of five consecutive letters of the alphabet within them. For instance, SUPERSTAR would have PQRST if there were a Q instead of an E, DEIGHTON would have DEFGH if there were an F instead of an I, and so forth. Take these five pairs of the required letter to have this string and the letter this would replace: these are QE, FI, JN, UA, CY. (I almost put KIMNOVAK in here, but I decided I'd rather have repeating strings RST than repeating letters, since the "I" would also have to get replaced in that entry.) Five 5-letter entries in the grid start and end with these letters: QUITE, FIERI, JOANN, UMBRA, and CADDY. From top to bottom, the middle letters of those grid entries spell ABIDE, the meta answer. This word itself could also have a string of five consecutive letters if the I were replaced with a C. (The only two single 5-letter words with this property that I found were ABIDE and ABODE; if we count hyphenated words, NO-PAR could also work.)
oldjudge 2s · 2023-08-26T17:02:29.762Z
This is a SAD puzzle at its' best. Great job Mikey!
Hector 3s · 2023-08-26T17:50:01.655Z
Very cool! Thanks for these great metas.
KayW 4s · 2023-08-26T21:48:06.597Z
Whew!! QUITE a meta. Every time I found a step, I'd get real excited for a minute. And then stare sadly at the resulting gibberish. But wowza!! What a meta, what a construction. And the usual fantastically PUNishing clues along the way. Thanks Mikey!
Yeah, I will be putting this reveal on a mug... Super cool idea!
Berto 3:09 · 2023-08-27T01:11:19.477Z
Lol - I was just writing ABIDE a PM when I noticed it was the middle letter of the words I was staring at!!! Still not quite sure why the middle letter, but I’ll take it. (Although a few minus points for submitting AURAE first, taking the letters out in same alphabetical place )
Just me trying something different with middle letters, haha. Still spells it out and still locks in the right words with first and last. Oh! If you ABIDE by something, it really centers you. (This is what we call a reach, folks.)
Hector 3s · 2023-08-27T05:05:22.101Z
Given that AB[C/I]DE fits the pattern, I suppose I should really have checked to see if the grid had something like CAPRI or CORGI --- which would have been a great/evil way to PAGEANT us. :-)
DJB 2s · 2023-08-27T08:26:08.840Z
Loved how the steps presented themselves!
boharr 4s · 2023-08-27T12:05:53.022Z
Very tough. Thanks, Mikey
Qmark 3s · 2023-08-27T13:34:37.202Z
Great meta, Mikey! Thanks!
Toast 🤓1:07 · 2023-08-27T18:31:47.894Z
SOSAD indeed. So, was the bowling PIN a clue by way of The Big Lebowski?
thank you for the nudges - needed them all! genius puzzle ... i should've known the cat was a red herring... i spent way too long looking for cats in the puzzle... YESIAM almost had "siamese"... XER had a backwards "rex"... then i tried taking the central entry literally and think like a cat... what would a cat want? PLAIT contained lait (milk)... i really thought i was onto something
At some point, I promise there will be a cat-themed meta! The original entry there was THINKLITTLEOFIT, and I figured that shifting it (at center) to THINKLIKEACAT with semi-buried longer entries (originally had LENDEIGHTON and FIRSTAVENUE but just couldn't pull it off) would lead to some red herrings (Ginger Cat would probably eat them).
Laura M 🤓22:44 · 2023-08-28T07:25:42.721Z
Awesome meta! I needed all the nudges, at least the 4 so far. Before that, I'd given up trying to find anything in the 5 longest across entries. Did you realize that not only is the grid almost a pangram (except Z) but there is at least one entry that starts with every letter (except Z)? And there's a 5-letter word starting with Z in the clues (zebra). I was sure that had to mean something!
I'm like, "There's no way an entry started with X." Nope, good 'ole XER! I'm not sure I realized this was a quasi-pangram (basically, not a pangram but quasi-pangram is fun to say). I heard if you do need to get some Zs, just attend one of my lectures! Thanks, as always, for solving!!
I K Snamhcok 3s · 2023-08-28T13:24:43.849Z
Beauty! I’m thinking that Mikey is quickly qualifying for the title of Evil Genius — and I mean that in a good way. I relied on a couple of nudges from another Muggle, so I didn’t enter for a prize.
FrankieHeck 10:49 · 2023-08-28T15:10:02.834Z
Wow, I got really stuck on the last step. I had previously written out the alphabet and looked for 5-letter almost-alphabetical strings as potential answers, but somehow when I teased out "abide" from the five words, I rejected it as not relating back to the title. Now that I get it, I really like it.
I'm really trying to figure out how this all came together, and I honestly don't know, haha. I was struggling with Week 4 ideas and had to ham-and-egg at least 10 ideas or so. And I think I realized the word "ABIDE" (hi, Peter, haha) was so close to "ABCDE" months prior. And I started fiddling around and somehow it morphed into a puzzle? Fun fact: THINKLIKEACAT was not actually the seed entry. In fact, I had THINKLITTLEOFIT when I was trying to do 15-by-15 and realized this title (I do have this book!!) worked perfectly.
MatthewL 5:29 · 2023-08-28T17:13:41.709Z
Nice one Mikey! Did not check the box for the prize, because I needed all 4 nudges plus another one from a friendly Muggle. But can still appreciate the construction (and the clues). Especially 56A, which gave me a good laugh. Thanks!
merlinnimue 🤓9:53 · 2023-08-28T19:02:41.862Z
Dude... that was a trip and a half
I went down so so many rabbit holes, including seeing consecutive letters but I would never have thought to look for imperfect sets of 5 without nudges... and then I was thrown off because I listed the 5-letter words by initial letter and didn't immediately see anything... it took me some time later and some squinting to see how to arrange the middles... I guess power hasn't been restored to my brain quite yet and won't quite make it to the left column... alas... thanks anyway for another great puzzle
Well I certainly waited for that.... I was all over the place. I had all the parts before the nudges and was desperately looking for the final 5. I had some of them but could not see the "hook" until I sent my work to someone and they said, "well I agree with this and this but not that" and I saw the pattern. I had been through the word so many times I knew exactly which words to use. I now know why Peter liked the puzzle so much. Great job Mikey.
I had all the parts, even noticed that JOANN can have its middle three letters replaced to be JKLMN, started looking in the clues and other entries for synonyms of JOANN etc., took the first words of the clues to the last five words, ... ordered the five words three different ways, finally noticed that one of the three ways I ordered them spelled AIBDE, thought, nahhh, he wouldn't, would he? Looked where those letters fell in the grid, decided to enter it, and here I am!
I never saw step one until the second set of nudges was published. And I required a shove to get to the answer. This one was definitely too hard for me!
Joe 🤓11:56 · 2023-09-01T16:26:14.751Z
Hoo boy. Finally made it. Brilliant, as always.
Tyrpmom 2s · 2023-09-01T17:14:01.774Z
Until center yourself all the nudges were unhelpful. You cant believe the crazy methods I tried with those five words and without a reason to use the middle letter I don’t know why it makes sense. All’s fair in meta world so I can’t complain too much.
And my apologies for the avant-garde-ness on this. You can still complain a little bit, haha. Probably needed a clue referencing "center" in the grid somewhere - I just did it a little differently with starting with one letter, ending with another, and so that was my next thought to place the letter. (Initially, they were to be five 3-letter words with two letters apiece, the replaced and the replacer, and one remaining, and that would've been it - but I wanted to keep it to 5). Thanks for solving in any case - I appreciate it!! I'm trying to be a little kinder in the final four months (I say that now, haha).
whimsy 18:08 · 2023-09-01T22:56:15.229Z
Whew! Was on my last gasp of breath until I centered myself. What a work out -- what a puzzle! Thanks, Mikey!
ReB 3s · 2023-09-02T02:01:38.951Z
Oh for PETE[R]'S sake!!! Needed all the nudges, but I did finally crawl ashore. Well done.
Bird Lives 4s · 2023-09-02T15:56:33.755Z
Without the nudge, I never would have thought to look at middle letters. I must remember to write key words down rather than just look at them in the grid.
Sendhil Revuluri 🤓5:30 · 2023-09-03T14:36:42.699Z
Puzzle: 53D. Meta: Waaaaaaaaay over my head. Thanks so much for the explanation — that's amazing! Congrats to all who solved!