Thanks, Schmeel. Did you also find the Easter eggs at 8D and 42D?
ajk 🤓10:36 · 2023-05-01T13:39:44.863Z
Fun one, thanks. Initially thought all of the group names would come into play, but (a) not a lot of vowels there, and (b) some of them seem ambiguous. Then I remembered the clue at 31D. :)
Thanks, ajk. In my earlier versions I didn't have 31D in the grid, and solvers had trouble finding the mechanism. It fit perfectly with the 'E' in 28A and also provided the first 'R' in MURDER.
I had the "One Under" from the start, but it took me a bit to catch on to the E part of it. Very clever, Cap'n Rick. A great way to start my week. Thanks!
Thanks, Darth. That was a common progression for the test solvers as well.
lbray53 2s · 2023-05-01T16:37:28.707Z
I also got caught up in the six unique group names for a bit. 41A headed me in the right direction but not too specifically. For some reason my brain switched to “keep your eye on the birdie” but CRANE did not work. I finally alit on the right letters.
Have you had any good sightings in your area this spring, Carolyn? We had a female rufous-sided towhee in the backyard the other day.
Carolyn 2s · 2023-05-02T00:15:45.429Z
Oh my, where to start! We have both California Towhees and Spotted Towhees in our yard, along with many others. My best birds today were Osprey, Brown Pelicans, and Elegant Terns hunting at Batiquitos Lagoon (Carlsbad, CA).
Just saw my first ruby-throated hummingbird at my feeder today.
Laura M 🤓9:12 · 2023-05-01T19:08:40.780Z
Nice! I pretty much backsolved, realizing that I could get the letters for "murder" from the entries under the birds, and only had the "bird-E" realization after that :-)
Had to resort to test solving notes to refresh the old memory, but have now once again arrived at the answer to the Cap'n's puzzle along with the rest of you buoys and gulls.
Ha! I see what you mean there, rjy. I have the same problem with my boat in the driveway (fortunately I'll be launching soon!). It's a good thing I clued it as a "philosophy" and not a "follower".
Wow that took a while to catch on! I totally missed the golf “one under” meaning… even though I’m a big golfer!). Instead, I read BIRDIE as “bird E” (rather than one under) — since each one had an E in it. Then, since I was sure DESCENT was key (because it’s smack in the middle, and about birds), I finally I tried going down from the E in each. Seeing MURDER emerge was exciting. I think I remember seeing that word/meaning in a puzzle pretty recently? Good challenge!
rjy 4s · 2023-05-02T02:12:17.248Z
totally missed that too - wow! this had layers of creativity!
Had combo experience of rjy and HeadinHome. Definitely keyed off DESCENT but EREADER was also helpful. Never thought about meaning of golf in the title until reading comments here. Worth an Eagle anyway - great job Cap’n! Thanks!
The title just hit me, the Bird E- brilliant! I did not get the aid from E reader I was supposed to until I ran out of other options. I saw the E finally in all the bird names but then tried to use it many different ways. Then I surmised if EREADER went down the E might too. I got MUR and knew where you were going.
Well THAT was interesting! Nice puzzle Cap, it went from “this is gonna be a snap” to “Curse you Cap’n” to “Oh my God, That’s it”
jim32809 🤓7:33 · 2023-05-02T16:52:23.525Z
I’ll admit I didn’t get the trick at all. I just started trying all the common birds I could think of and after about a dozen tries I got the right one.
Extremely clever and fun as per usual! Thank you. I saw the bird synonyms and learned what a descent was so went to the sedge, gaggle thing, then the Bird -E and one under for Murder >> CROW. Before I solved I was so proud of the new word I learned so yesterday I quizzed my mountain bike friends if they knew what a group of woodpeckers is called? A bevy of complete strangers walking by overheard and joined our herd for the discussion. None knew the answer but all were quick to let me knew what they did know: Murder of crows and what different local woodpeckers looked like! Very funny slice of human nature while enjoying nature!
Great story, Snood. Glad you solved the "murder" mystery!
ReB 3s · 2023-05-03T17:41:02.709Z
Was on the right track all along (looking to spell out a group name and looking below the six themers), but needed the final nudge to complete the missing link as to where to look. Well constructed