Had to go back to the title (aha, "Missing!") to be extra sure -- although hygienist should have been enough. Otherwise you would have been left wondering about a submission of Donna Karan. ;o) (Yes, I will call the dentist and make my overdue appointment this week.)
Explanation: I like that this one is a two-prong mechanism, in a way. First, six entries - relatively symmetrically - are missing a key component: TURNS (LOOSE), WHEAT (PASTE), PAINT (BRUSH), (SWEET) HEART, (PICKS) CLEAN, LIGHT (SABER). These six missing words can all precede or follow TOOTH in standard items and phrases (3-D came up during the fill, and that was fitting).
But also, anchor entry 58-A seems clued in an odd way that would suggest something else is going on with the letters of the alphabet. Indeed, two letters are missing from this grid and all the clues as well: "D" and "K." (I had about 15 uses of "D" in the first edit of the clues, even when I thought I caught them all! Things like "and" and regular past tense had to be avoided). Phonetically, DK suggests DECAY, which also reinforces the six TOOTH-related words having a piece missing (decaying) from the grid. This finalizes to TOOTH DECAY, a fitting candy-related answer for an end-of-October meta! Brush and floss, folks!
KayW 🤓9:46 · 2023-10-28T18:42:37.797Z
Wow! Very clever Mikey. Thanks for a meta I can really sink my teeth into.
boharr 3s · 2023-10-28T19:08:59.565Z
Oh my teeth are sore. Thanks, Mikey!
merlinnimue 🤓12:15 · 2023-10-28T19:56:22.442Z
ah i missed the quasi-pangram, as usual i am too dumb for you geniuses, sorry for bothering you
great stuff as always, definitely worthy of (a) plaque
SamKat9 🤓16:18 · 2023-10-28T20:14:19.915Z
Very clever, I guessed several other things before this came to me! Thank you for the puzzle!
oldjudge 2s · 2023-10-28T20:33:21.429Z
Fun, but not in love with Puget being a fill. Before you know the TOOTH link you think PUGET SOUND works. I think the puzzle would have been better without that fill. Thanks Mikey!
That's fair. You're right on that, and I changed the clue as a result. Sorry about the kerfuffle that may have complicated the solve! Will update the PDF and PUZ and make an announcement in Muggles when I get home; I'm out and about now (yes, buying cat food).
The original 50A had me searching for another "missing" piece, which I assumed was needed for a 100% click. Thanks for correcting it. I appreciated the indirect mention in 44D, too.
Oh, man! I didn't even notice that, Ben. (Obviously, I wasn't totally in the zone on this one. I'll blame it on the piles of essays I had to grade this weekend. haha)
lbray53 2s · 2023-10-29T16:00:46.953Z
I really wanted the answer to be FRONT TEETH since that was "missing" from 58 across to get TWO FRONT TEETH!
I thought the same thing since the TWO there surely had to mean something. I understand its significance now.
I K Snamhcok 2s · 2023-10-30T01:21:41.121Z
Now that was a puzzle I could sink my teeth into. Some filled, some crowned, some deadened by root canals, one replaced with an implant … you’ve raised an, ahem, sensitive concern for me, Mikey. Seriously, very fun. Thanks, Mr. G!
I'm not sure I want to find tooth decay! Probably has to do with the seasonal candy. Interesting puzzle Mikey!
MatthewL 🤓9:55 · 2023-11-01T14:19:41.138Z
Very clever puzzle, Mikey! Found the missing words thing fairly quickly, except I had LICKS CLEAN as opposed to PICKS. Tried a bunch of different ways to make sense of it, but could not. Finally saw the tooth connection. Never saw the DK thing -- I guessed TOOTH FAIRY first (because who comes to collect your missing teeth?) and then finally DECAY. As luck would have it, I've got a dentist appointment next week, so good timing on this! Thanks.
Clever. I totally lucked into DECAY; even with the nudges, that part of the puzzle wasn't sticking out to me. I really need to start using that program that I've seen mentioned, which shows how many times each letter has been used- that would have made the absence of D and K obvious!
I like TOOTH FAIRY for an answer, so I think that's legit! Edited to accept that.
Laura M 14:40 · 2023-11-02T00:30:17.596Z
Needed the hints! I pretty much thought of everything except that the missing words should be 5 letters, and half my words were wrong. I should have thought of TOOTH with DK though!
Carolyn 3s · 2023-11-02T21:03:55.345Z
I saw the missing d and k right away, but I had several wrong words. Nudges put me straight. Clever!
Bird Lives 3s · 2023-11-04T15:43:30.807Z
I got the TOOTH part right away. Without looking at the nudges I could think of only two possibilities -- FAIRY and DECAY. I couldn't find confirmation for either so I didn't submit. Now it turns out both were acceptable.
Embarrassing not to get the second part since I used letter sounds in my own puzzle less than two months ago.