Reminds me of
https://crosswordfiend.com/2014/08/10/muller-monthly-music-meta-august-2/ ...
Or, actually,
not that, but someone else's version of that same song's theme, probably later, where they clued one of the ingredients as SEAN CONNERY and the other as, I think, King LOUIS XIV.... Feels like either a WSJ or a Gaffney (or both...) but I now can't for the life of me find that puzzle. Anyone else remember?
For a moment I thought this would be about synonymous slightly off phrases. I wanted GINNtonic, amberALE, mulledWINE, SHOPkeeper. But not today, rabbit, not today.