Good job, DIS! Yeah, I had to lead people away from the song.
MatthewL 🤓6:12 · 2024-01-01T22:40:56.090Z
Finally got it -- just had to keep poking at it. Stumbled onto the RAIN thing fairly quickly due to the lyric in the title, but took me foreeevvvver to find BAHRAIN and GERAINT (that one, I had to backsolve for). Nice puzzle, Rick! Way to being the new year.
Thanks for solving, Matthew! Yeah, I figured that BAHRAIN and especially GERAINT would be tricky to spot.
Sharkicicles 2s · 2024-01-04T19:42:26.302Z
I got BAHRAIN pretty quickly, but figured that GET was symmetrical so it had to be SOMETHING... GERAINT is a new one for me, and I just brute-force backsolved that one with Google.
Thanks, Sharky. Yes, GERAINT and ENID (usually clued as "Wife of Geraint") have been around crossword puzzles for a long time. They've been becoming more and more obscure, so I thought I'd try to freshen them up a bit.
Thanks, Cap'n - it took me some time to see it, but a lot of fun throughout the process. Definitely a good "aha" when what I needed to do clicked, and then a merry chase to the solve
Wow, great, and very difficult puzzle. Early on I thought, "hey that is the start to a song, I'll bet...", but I was trying to remove the letters RAIN either where they appeared together or in total - BIG mess. Then I got caught with trying to add to the end or beginning as I "usually" do with a Cap'n; nice changeup. I should have suspected with some of the odd answers. Actually I did with NAURU and that was the one that finally helped me. I saw it doing a nudge request and then Meg confirmed that I was on the right track but not to get locked into a simple addition. You know, when I saw BARS clued musically with this group a flare should have gone up, and ENID...well you might see an archaic reference like that in a DrTom, but never a Cap. Excellent use of the words Cap, and what a way to start the year!
Thanks for the nice comments, Tom. Glad you enjoyed it!
HeadinHome 🤓4:22 · 2024-01-02T15:56:45.450Z
I was another one who was removing the letters of RAIN from the grid. For a good number of entries, this left only one letter (or that one letter repeated, as in LIARLIAR). FWIW, I thought the answer to THAT meta was getting a little bit close to sunglasses (though of course it never was going to have an A, with RAIN removed… ). This was really fun to figure out once someone corrected my method! I even grokked GERAINT thinking that sounded like something from an old epic (it rang a bell)… though maybe I was thinking of Gawain. ANYhoo… kudos on a great first puzzle of 2024.
Thank you, Berto. Yeah, those 2 themers were the trickiest for solvers to find.
hoover 3s · 2024-01-04T01:53:41.359Z
Me three
whimsy 🤓10:02 · 2024-01-02T21:32:21.115Z
Wow -- a toughie! I needed that flashback nudge! I was glad that Geraint rang a distant bell for me too, Headin', and that the whole puzzle didn't turn out to be in Olde English or something! :-) Thanks for the challenge, Cap'n!
I just know that if I asked Rick - why in the world would you pick an obscure Knight of the Round table as part of a meta, was that somehting that had to happen, he would answer (and my sincerest apologies to Ira Gershwin):
Thanks for hanging in there, Darth. It's an oldie, but hopefully one that's familiar to most people.
Cindy Heisler 2s · 2024-01-03T17:14:27.139Z
I thought of the song immediately. I couldn't find where to take away rain and then I tried adding it to the beginning of grid words which, of course, didnt work. Finally caught on after a muggle nudge. Good one, Cap'n.
Beaming now, but spent yesterday/today red as a beet, dry as a bone, blind as a bat, mad as a hatter, hot as a hare, full as a flask. That's what a great meta (and anticholinergic toxicity) will do to ya! Thanks for the nudges and SOS Cap'n. You just keep getting better and better!
Thank you, Kay. I'm glad you enjoyed my meta. It was a bit tougher than usual for me.
Bird Lives 2s · 2024-01-04T03:30:58.333Z
Excellent puzzle, lousy solver. Even when I got the idea that RAIN had to be brought back in, I at first thought it would be at the beginning of end of the entries. I think there actually is something called a "rain table."
knew the song thanks to claritin commercials... had BAMIG for the longest time... figured the E had to be esme or enid so spent awhile googling salinger characters and idylls of the king characters until i got it... thank goodness for ctrl+F... thanks for the puzzle cap'n
Thanks for solving, Phil. Who says you can't learn a few things while solving meta puzzles, right? Poor ENID was getting tired of always being clued as "Wife of Geraint".