Great puzzle with lots of fun clues! I had to look up "The Point!" because I had no hope for the 57A/31D crossing otherwise. Now I have some new listening material too :)
"Tonight: I eat a cabbage, James throws a bird out of a car, and Hammond forgets the abbreviation for America." "___." (Top Gear quote)
12A
Karma police?
15A
Salmon's sons, maybe
16A
It could star a British gecko
18A
Emotion exhibited when you just can't get that one corner of a crossword puzzle, maybe
19A
THE ___ (anagram of THEY SEE)
20A
Certain sporty Seattleite
22A
Joey of kids' literature
24A
Proof of a history of smoking, sometimes
26A
Closest chum (Abbr.)
27A
Big works
28A
Rapper on Madvillainy's "Accordion"
30A
Company with an arrow hidden in its logo
34A
Norm the Genie's living quarters in Fairly OddParents
37A
Time out?
38A
King Of the Fairies, in Shakespeare
39A
Acid found in lemons
41A
Prefix for -tarian
42A
Of respectable quality
45A
___ is Dead (book by TomSka)
46A
A certain degree
47A
Barrel's partner
48A
"¿Qué es ___?"
49A
Sickness that one may be down with
51A
Genre of 51-Down
52A
Body part that Bob Oblong lacks
54A
Leigh Cook, or Ray, cook
57A
Protagonist of Harry Nilsson's album "The Point!" (this may seem like some random shitty fill but trust me I grew UP on this album)
59A
Locked up
60A
Bird in the hand?
61A
Word at the end of many a Discord message
62A
"___ more bright ideas?"
Verticali
1D
___ Young (1st overall draft pick of the 2018 NBA drafts)
2D
___ Clark (player of ___ Manbeast in TomSka's sketch "The Wish")
3D
Today or tomorrow, maybe
4D
3/15
5D
Tree named after some guy named Douglas, probably
6D
Mel of Crosswordese
7D
Cheerleader artist (BTW the Felix Jaehn remix is the version you've heard, not the original, look it up after this)
8D
Number of Spanish words in this puzzle
9D
Substance that may look like lemonade but definitely isn't (don't try and check)
10D
They might weep (oh god kate why would you recommend this clue)
11D
Corona and Coors
13D
"Shoutout to my Asian girls, let the lights ___" (quote from a Smosh Pit video in which they read off their cringy DMs)
14D
Goes nuts
17D
Good ___ (certain oxymoron)
21D
Critter that makes Danny Elfman want to dance, in an Oingo Boingo song
23D
Dump out
24D
Den, for one
25D
Per product
29D
“'What’s the name of the bishop?' 'That’s actually stand-up comedian ___ Levy. He was the host of MTV’s Your Face or Mine?'” -John Mulaney
31D
Anime that a Patricia Taxxon album was named after (the title cat even appears on the album cover!)
32D
Some Mideastern men
33D
Knife used for precision in clay sculpting
34D
Apt rhyme for "chop"
35D
President known for his 55-Down
36D
Italian merchant who's only well-known because of America
39D
Summer camp instructor-to-be, for short
40D
In a perfect world
42D
Give a talking to
43D
World of Warcraft monster
44D
Tribe also known as the Teton Sioux
49D
See 50-Down
50D
___ of the 49-Down (America)
51D
Musician Lou
53D
Blue Sky movie whose protagonist's name is a homophone of the first word in the compa- yeah this clue is too long-winded and complicated lemme just say it's a movie with birds