Good morning Muggles, and welcome to Muggle Meta Monday!
This puzzle – titled “Watching the Detectives” – is part 3 of my four-puzzle Detective Suite (the first being “Elementary, My Dear Watson,” and the second being “A Figure in Hiding”). The topic of the suite is one of my favorites, fictional detectives. No intimate or complete knowledge is needed on any of these sleuths, but a visit with Mr. E… I mean Mr. G… might be required for corroboration.
This one actually grew from the title of one of my favorite songs from one of my favorite singer/songwriters: Elvis Costello (and though it’s not meta-related, you should really check the song out on YouTube. I got to hear him perform it live in a little club in Utica, a few days before his infamous debut on Saturday Night Live in 1977).
Anyway, as much as I enjoyed reading detective stories, I enjoyed watching film and TV adaptations of those stories and their detectives just as much. While some of the actors were way off from the images I conjured up from the books’ descriptions, many – even most -- were pretty spot on. How about you? Do you have any examples of where the actor was just wrong for the part (let’s not even talk about Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher)? Any that were dead-on perfect (to that list, I’d include Maury Chaykin as Nero Wolfe and Jeremy Brett as Sherlock Holmes)? A great topic for a campfire roundtable, for sure.
Oh… and did I mention that this suite also has a mega-meta answer? Well, it does, so keep track of the puzzles as you solve them. And now, adjust the aluminum foil on the rabbit ears, fire up the Jiffy Pop and sit back… the game is afoot!