Explanation: Per the echo of the title in 1-D, the word "wind" must be relevant, and that word appears embedded as part of other words in 6 entries' clues: NFL, ONES, TOY, YONDER, ENGLISH, TIDY). Maybe that's the whole mechanism! But the initial letters spell out NOT YET, implying there's at least one other step. (I didn't have to spell out anything here - but this reminds me of an old puzzle in GAMES magazine once. It was a simple matching exercise, where you matched up things in a standard way, and it spelled out something like NOT CORRECT. You then had to think of a more lateral way to pair them, and the final message was I FOOLED YOU or something similar.
So, then, we look elsewhere. And six entries in the grid are those windy words with "wind" substituted for another letter. For instance, REZ going down comes from replacing the "wind" in "rewind" with a "Z," and so forth. These six replaced letters spell ZEPHYR, the meta answer and just a cool word in general. (And, no, this has nothing to do with the number 92, haha.)
A slight inelegance that I didn't catch until last night: the word "rewind" could go to either REZ or REX; however, if it goes to REX, extracting the "X," there is no other way "Windex" could be represented since *EX is nowhere else in the grid. A very recent MGWCC had something similar, where I think both OUNCE and POUND were two entries that could have fit one alternate clue and you had to go beyond to use logic. Logic's fair in metas!
Right, I'm hoping that led people to look at an alternate path!
Carolyn 2s · 2024-04-27T21:34:30.618Z
That would have been my wild guess, but so nice to figure it out! Excellent puzzle.
HeadinHome 7:06 · 2024-04-28T00:00:33.980Z
True confession: I saw a Z in the top of the puzzle and couldn’t stop thinking ZEPHYR the whole time. So it was a guess… should have made myself work harder, because that was so clever!
i was also naticked by that square! i guessed Z first and ran the entire alphabet... only to find out i had an error elsewhere in the grid at TOY/YIP i had TOP/PIP... there are some tops that you wind up!
HeadinHome 7:06 · 2024-04-29T00:34:44.201Z
I had TOP there too! I had to reveal the square because I never questioned that answer (pip should have given it away as wrong, but nope).
I actually figured that would be Naticky (I love putting in the literary references), but I also feared that to try to reference it in anyway forced alluding to the Z, which seemed too much of a nudge toward ZEPHYR, as HeadinHome kind of found out organically!
An Ephemeral Collation 🤓10:47 · 2024-04-27T23:45:16.974Z
Really nice puzzle on the whole. I really like the freshness of the jocular/punny tone that you go for with your cluing but personally found it challenging to make inroads in the NE owed to it.
Haha, thanks! Yeah, I let the cluing get wild sometimes, but I do recognize that might make things a bit challenging at times! Thanks so much for solving!!
KayW 🤓3:00 · 2024-04-28T03:55:42.177Z
Fantastic metanism and puzzle as usual! I found the trap almost immediately but it took me ages to figure out what else to do with those clues.
lbray53 6s · 2024-04-28T12:01:49.584Z
Loved this one! It would have been easier if I did not have RED for 7D unntil I figured out what I needed it to be.
Thank you! I've read both of the Kazuo Ishiguro books and want to read the Talty short story collection! He has a new novel coming out in the fall, I believe. I felt that would be Naticky, which I try to avoid, but it was a bit unavoidable (and I love Ishiguro so when Kazuo came up on the fill, I had to use it).
hoover 3s · 2024-05-03T07:46:32.759Z
Same! I ended up using REX twice and thinking there might be a spelling problem. I shoulda had more confidence in MikeyG!
Lol. My little rabbit connected WIND and CUBS WIN, so tried to think of how the "Windy City", especially with your "It's a meta!" cluing for METROPOLIS. (Chicago?... Nope, only 7 letters!). Trying to parse 1D as WIN "D" and scouring the grid and clues also leads to... well, 8 words! I found the first secret message, which I then followed with another secret message: If you remove WIN from "winnow" and "wintry" clues, it reads TRY NOW! Hmm... I realize I'm now having a conversation with a rabbit! Maybe I should type in HARVEY just for fun?
I've wanted to see "Harvey" for a while! My mom loves Jimmy Stewart, but I think she said that movie was a bit too odd for her, haha. Whoa, you were on a "whirlwind" in this one! 'Tis meta life sometimes!
whimsy 15:05 · 2024-04-28T12:29:55.719Z
I too surmised zephyr and was right, but without looking at any hints or comments here I went back to the grid determined to backsolve. But all the rest of the evening it was a case of success being NOT YET. Finally figured it out after heading up to bed, sometime around midnight. Quoting Dr Seuss: PUP is UP! Thanks, Mikey for this super trickster!
MAN was I overcomplicating this lovely puzzle which I made a 5 or 6 despite MikeyG's difficulty rating. I got soooo down a rabbit hole with WIND TRAP and a DUNE reference. WIth DROPLET right there and people winnowing water out of DEW condensed from CLOUDS with the METROPOLIS clue containing the word meta and Zendaya's armor a visual reference to the robot in the film Metropolis...how could I be wrong. I did see the "WINDS" but there were only 4 (dummy, look closer). But when I said WOOD wind and WOODY and then saw WINDEX and REX I knew it had to be somehting. I got the PHYR so knew what it had to be and then finally backtracked since there were not that many Z's and REWIND seemed to be a natural (though I did not see it until I went back). The "dwindles" was so well hidden I would never have seen it. I spent a lot of time trying to use WINtry, WINnow. A great puzzle and lovely AHA! Mikey you blew my mind.
So, how does 92 relate to Zephyr? The Lincoln Zephyr was certainly out of production by then, it doesn't seem to tie to Harry Caray, enlighten me please. (OK, just read and see that the puzzle number has no relevance this time)
The English horn clue had me thinking about wind instruments, and then seeing KAZUO, one letter off from kazoo, got me totally fixated on that path.
Stepped back enough to see the other wind clues and get "not yet" but then was stuck there for a day until nudged to keep looking at those clues.
Laura M 🤓16:55 · 2024-04-29T02:39:22.497Z
Love it! Very nice touch with the NOT YET!
Bird Lives 3s · 2024-04-29T12:38:06.582Z
This was a brilliant puzzle, and I wonder what triggered the idea. I followed the red herring, and it took me a while rethink the windy clues. Now if only I could save this word for Scrabble.
Berto 1s · 2024-04-29T15:27:09.755Z
Had all but given up on this, waiting for nudges, but whistled through the MMM quickly and had the rest of my 3 hour flight ahead of me so gave it another look. Lots of turbulence maybe helped me see all the wind in the clues. I fell face first in the trap, but started writing all those windy clue words out and WOOD and EX jumped out! Great Aha moment - hopefully the pilot will find some smooth air so I can celebrate with a mid-morning coffee!
MatthewL 🤓11:40 · 2024-04-29T18:17:39.587Z
Was stuck in the trap forever, but gave it a fresh look today and finally saw WOODY and REX (nice double up on the Toy Story names, by the way) and was off to the races. Like many others, I had fixated on ZEPHYR but could not find a way to make it work until now. Thanks for the puzzle, Mikey!